Lecture 9: Logical Positivism & Unity of Science
I. Logical Positivism and Operationism
Auguste Comte (1798-1857):
Ernst Mach (1838-1916): Sensationistic Physics
1885 - Analysis of sensations:
All of physical theory
and laws can be framed in terms of sensations
Scientific meaning is provided through
functional
statements about
the relationships between sensations
(eg. F=MxA) in quantifiable terms
Relativism is expected: Influenced Albert Einstein
Vienna Circle ~ 1925:
The marriage of logic and empiricism
Unification of Science
along with the expulsion
of metaphysics and ethics was their goal
Theoretical terms can be linked to observation
terms or "Protocol
Sentences"
through theoretical
statements of the relationships between such
observations and
theoretical constructs
Verifiability
principle: "The
meaning of a proposition
is the method of its verification." The truth
or
meaning of a statement is to be found in the
verification (proof) made by
observations
Laws of Science
are summary statements about
regularly correlated observations and predictions
Explanation
is found in the verification of determinations
or predictions
Three groups of Logical (Neo) Positivists,
supporters of:
Sensationism (phenomenalism),
"physical" Language &
Physicalism (realism)
Percy Bridgman (1882-1961): Operationism
1927 - The logic of modern physics
Operational analysis: "the concept is synonymous with the corresponding set of operations" needed to perform the observation (physical and mental operations)
This is not a method for definitions, but for analyzing or sharpening the meanings of concepts already in place
Phenomenalism: Knowledge is limited to an individual's observations
vs.
Operationism: S.S.Stevens (1935) & E.G.Boring (1936)
Terms must be defined operationally to be scientifically meaningful
The "'Operational
definition', as practiced in
psychology,
seeks to universalize the language community by
reducing a concept to an observation"
Experimental Methods: Statistical inference
Ronald A. Fisher (1890-1962) ANOVA
We can make
inferences
about the world through
an examination of the
probabilities
that our
experimental treatments are due solely to chance.
Null
Hypothesis:
A statement that there is
no difference between treatments and controls.
Rejecting the Null does not mean proof or verification
of the experimental hypothesis, only a lack of falsification.
The Golden Age of Behaviorism: Theories of Learning
Edward Chace
Tolman (1886-1959):
Purposive behaviorism
Influenced by neo-realism and gestalt psychology
Purpose and hunger could be objectively observed
Operational behaviorism examines the functional relationships between independent anddependent variables
Intervening variables:
Theoretical constructs
representing hypothetical processes) which
enable the prediction
of dependent variables.
For example:
B=fx(S,P,H,T,A)
Cognitive
maps:
Internal representations of
the external world which are often acquired
through "latent learning"
Clark
Leonard Hull (1884-1952):
Letter To Spence
Mechanism & reductionism
Mathematization of psychology: "physics envy"
Quantifiable prediction and
control
are goals of psychology
Underlying realism (in opposition to Mach & Bridgman)
Hypothetico-Deductivism: "Explicitly stated postulates" derived from a theory provide testable predictions of that theory.
sEr = sHr x D x V x K - sIr - Ir
Gordon W. Allport (1897-1967):
Personology & Personality
Visited Freud ~1920 and embarrassed himself with a story
1937 - Personality: A psychological interpretation
Paranjpe (1993): Style over substance & the loss of personhood
Personality vs. Personology: Two worldviews
Naturwissenschaften vs. Geisteswissenschaften
Personology is marked by understanding persons
through the "trilogy of mind" enabling them
to be ethico-legal
agents of responsibility
Trilogy of mind is comprised of
cognition (thinking),
conation
(willing) and
affect
(feeling)
1939- APA Presidential Address:
Science is "empirical, mechanistic, quantitative,
nomothetic, analytic, and uses operational concepts"
"Why not allow
psychology
as a science is [that is]
... rational, teleological, qualitative, idiographic,
synoptic, and even non-operational"
Personality is a dynamic organization of traits or dispositions
Cardinal traits: Ruling passions
in all experience
Central trait: Behavioral themes such as aggressiveness
or sentimentality
Secondary traits: Less frequently displayed behaviors
Study on values: Examined 18,000
adjectives from
a standard dictionary
1950
- The Historical Background of social psychology:
Hedonism, Egoism, Sympathy, Imitation,
The Crowd, Group mind
1954 - The nature of prejudice