Looking back to the
Rebirth of Positivism:
Psychology and The
Golden Age of Behaviorism
Edward
Chace Tolman (1886-1959): Purposive behaviorism
Influenced by neo-realism and gestalt psychology
Purpose and hunger could be objectively observed
Operational
behaviorism examines the
functional relationships
between independent
and dependent variables
Intervening variables:
Theoretical constructs representing hypothetical
processes) which enable the
prediction of dependent
variables. Theoretically they are the link between stimulus and response,
sometimes thought of as real causes. For
example: B=fx(S,P,H,T,A) where s=stimuli, p=physiological drive, h=heredity,
t=training, a=age
Clark
Leonard Hull (1884-1952): Mechanism & reductionism
Mathematization of
psychology: "physics envy"
Quantifiable prediction and control are goals of psychology Underlying realism (in opposition to Mach & Bridgman)
Hypothetico-Deductivism: "Explicitly stated postulates" derived from a theory provide testable predictions of that theory.
sEr = sHr x D x V x K - sIr - Ir
The Birth of
Experimentl Methods & Statistical Inference
Ronald A. Fisher (1890-1962)
We can make
inferences
about the world through
an examination of the
probabilities that
our
experimental treatments are due solely to chance.
Commentary on positivism in Psychology
While we set up our experiments to test the null hypothesis - that there is no difference between the treatment groups we then turn to the alternate (Real) hypothesis and either reject or fail to reject it. This model of science is built on the notion of falsification (based upon probabilities), however, we have a very strong tendency to turn around and "accept" or "prove" our theories based upon the rejection of the null hypothesis. This is bad science according to Sir Karl Popper, and it represents the tendency towards positivism that we all are subject to.
Thus positivism is an attitude of acceptance of theories, ideas, truths based upon the confirmation established through observational methods.